Toll Free
877.485.1973 |
T:
541.485.1973 |
F:
541.683.7543
| P.O. Box 11248 | Eugene, OR 97440
Home
Siegfried Engelmann 1931-2019
About
NIFDI's Mission
Who We Are
Board of Directors
Home Office Staff
On-Site Consultants
Contact Us
Donate
NIFDI Press
Testimonials
What is DI?
Basic Philosophy
Common Myths & Misconceptions
DI vs. di
Origins of Authentic DI
Siegfried "Zig" Engelmann on Instruction
Project Follow Through
Intro to DI Video Series
Timeline of DI Events
The Programs
About the Programs
DI and the Common Core State Standards
Placement Testing
Program Field Testing
Found an error in a DI program?
ELL/ELD
Direct Instruction Spoken English (DISE)
Español to English
Mathematics
Connecting Math Concepts
Corrective Math
DISTAR Arithmetic
Essentials for Algebra
Funnix Math
Reading
Corrective Reading
Funnix Reading
Horizons
Reading Mastery
REWARDS
Science & Social Studies
Academic Core
REWARDS Plus Social Studies
Understanding U.S. History
Spelling
Spelling Mastery
Spelling Through Morphographs
Writing & Language
Essentials for Writing
Expressive Writing
Language for Learning
Language for Thinking
Sentence Copying Program (Handwriting)
Using DI at Home
Funnix Reading
Funnix Math
Teach Your Child to Read in 100 Easy Lessons
How to be Successful
Overview of the DI Model
Effective Leadership
Ensuring Sufficient Personnel
Focusing on Student Performance
Practicing
Scheduling Sufficient Instructional Time
Teaching to Mastery
Using a Single Instructional Program
Success Stories
Services
Overview of NIFDI Services
Training
Assessment
Preservice
In-Service
Video In-Services
Coaching
Peer Coaches
Virtual Visits
Off-Site Support
Conference Calls
Data Analysis
Remote Support
Online DI Coaching
Implementation Options
Getting Started
Services FAQ
Research
NIFDI's Research Office
History of DI Research
Beginnings
Project Follow Through
Over 40 Years of Research
Recent Research
Efficacy
Implementation
Technical Reports
White Papers
Reviews of Direct Instruction
Common Myths & Misconceptions
Evidence of Effectiveness
Literature Reviews
Meta-Analyses
What Works Clearinghouse
Database
About the Database
Tips for Using the Database
Search The Database
Research Article Request
DI Bibliographies
Comprehensive Bibliography
Subject Area Bibliographies
Journal of DI (Archive)
Effective School Practices (Archive)
Researchers
Directory of Researchers
Fellowships
Educational Impact Calculator
Events
About Our Training Events
National DI Conference (Eugene)
Administrator's Institute
Institute on Becoming a DI Trainer
Coaching Institute
Excellence in Education Awards
Placement Testing Your Students
Conference Keynotes
Southwest DI Training Conference
Institute on Becoming an Effective DI Trainer
Placement Testing
Academies
Creating and Delivering In-services
Leadership Academy
Coaching Academies
Analyzing Data, Classroom Observations, and Providing Feedback
Enhanced Coaching and Facilitating Professional Development
Webinars & Forums
Origins of Authentic DI
Routines and Expectations
Critical Phrasing
Teaching RMSE in the Virtual Classroom
Teaching Corrective Reading Decoding in the Virtual Classroom
Forums
Store
Resources
Join the DI Discussion List
Members
Membership Overview
Become a Member/Renew Membership
Links
Share Your DI Story!
Find a School Using DI
News/Blogs
Get NIFDI News!
NIFDI News! (Archive)
In the Media
Latest News in DI
DI News (Archive)
Blog: Dr. Martin Kozloff on Education
Most recent Blog: Dr. Kerry Hempenstall on DI
About Dr. Hempenstall
Referenced Documents
Kerry's Complete List of Blogs
Free Downloads
Common Core State Standards
Reading Mastery Signature Edition
Connecting Math Concepts: Comprehensive Edition
Community Advocates for DI
Data Collection Forms and Tools
General Documents
New to DI
DI in Middle School
Essential Elements
New School Data Forms
New School Handouts
Scheduling
Presentations
Programs
ELL/ELD
Direct Instruction Spoken English (DISE)
Español to English
Mathematics
Connecting Math Concepts
Corrective Math
DISTAR Arithmetic
Essentials for Algebra
Funnix Math
Reading
Corrective Reading
Funnix Reading
Horizons
Reading Mastery
Teach Your Child to Read
REWARDS
Science and Social Studies
Academic Core
REWARDS Plus Science and Social Studies
Understanding U.S. History
Spelling
Spelling Mastery
Spelling Through Morphographs
Writing and Language
Cursive Writing
Essentials for Writing
Expressive Writing
Language for Learning
Language for Thinking
Language for Writing
RMSE Sentence Copying Program
Research
Success Stories
Suggested Reading
What Works Clearinghouse (WWC)
Videos
Distance Learning Videos
Intro to DI Video Series
Origins of Authentic DI
Implementing Direct Instruction Successfully: An Online Tutorial
Video In-Services
Schools Receiving NIFDI Support
Reading Mastery Format Practice Series
Reading Mastery Setup and Training Series
Siegfried "Zig" Engelmann
Siegfried "Zig" Engelmann on Instruction
Selected Writings Discussion with Zig
National Direct Instruction Conference Keynotes
Video Supplements
Differences between a Direct Instruction reading approach and a balanced reading approach among elementary school students
McGahey, J.
Abstract:
This study compared the effect of a Direct Instruction (DI) reading program and a Balanced Reading (BR) approach on the reading comprehension of 88 second, third, and fourth grade students, at two different schools. The Iowa Tests of Basic Skills (ITBS) was administered to both groups over three years, beginning when the students entered the second grade. Results indicated students in the DI school demonstrated significant gains in reading comprehension skills in comparison to students in the BR group. Students in the DI group recorded positive gains in NCE mean reading comprehension scores following the first year of implementation, while students in the BR group were unable to demonstrate positive gains on NCE mean reading comprehension scores until the third year of implementation. Following the third year of implementation, both groups demonstrated similar decreases in mean scores. Results for Caucasian and African American students indicated no significant differences on reading comprehension scores within each form of instruction over the three year period. (Copyright © 2011, National Institute for Direct Instruction (NIFDI). All rights reserved).
Research areas:
Project Follow Through
Year:
2002
Main publication type:
Program Effectiveness
Subtype:
Article
Source:
Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Auburn University, Dissertation Abstracts International, 63 (06A), 2147
Design type:
Posttest Only Control Group Design
Fidelity monitored:
No
Students included:
Elementary students, at-risk students, disadvantaged students, African American students, Caucasian students, low-SES students
Other tags:
Reading comprehension, Iowa Tests of Basic Skills (ITBS), vocabulary, Balanced Reading
Location/Setting:
Georgia, rural area, elementary school
Hits: 4376
Back
Upcoming Events
Introduction to Teaching Authentic Direct Instruction
02-10-2021 8:00 am
Free Event
Forgot your password?
Forgot your username?
Create an account
Latest News
NIFDI Offers Virtual Coaching Academy!
Dynamic Displays for Corrective Reading Decoding Now Available!
Direct Instruction Featured in National Review Article!
Program Focus: Corrective Mathematics